| Children |
| | 1. Charles Davis VAIL, b. 5/27/1861, Germantown, PA  |
| | 2. Frederick Clifton VAIL, b. 7/31/1875, NJ d. yes, NJ  |
| | 3. Susan Mansfield VAIL, b. 2/3/1874, Germantown, PA  |
| | 4. Ernest MacDowell VAIL, b. 8/16/1872, NJ d. yes, NJ  |
| | 5. Louise De Pui VAIL, b. 9/18/1870, Germantown, PA  |
| | 6. William Aubrey sr. VAIL, b. 3/21/1869, NJ d. yes, unlisted  |
| | 7. Emily Rachel VAIL, b. 8/5/1865, NJ d. yes, NJ  |
| | 8. George Stroud VAIL, b. 4/29/1865, PA d. 5/4/1914, SanFrancisco, CA  |
| | 9. Mary Hallowell VAIL, b. 12/31/1863, NJ d. yes, NJ  |
| | 10. Eleanor Stroud VAIL, b. 7/13/1862, NJ d. yes, NJ  |
| | 11. Arthur Henry VAIL, b. 2/11/1878, Germantown,PA  |
|